Perry Shepherd had been the first of the three private investigators hired by Ford to investigate the Meadows case. The reason was quite simple: Shepherd’s roots in the Berlin police department, in these matters, ran deepest of all. He’d been Harmony Wright’s senior partner. He was retired now. He’d been on the force when the original kidnappings occurred, when Foster was arrested and convicted. His were the sins that started them all.
For these reasons, Shepherd initially appeared as if he wasn’t going to accomplish anything at all. That was why Pawley was hired. Ford believed in Shepherd, but Shepherd himself considered it Ford forcing a sense of redemption Shepherd himself didn’t find necessary. He didn’t feel the need to defend his work. This had the effect of provoking a defensive attitude. He resented Ford, and let him know under no uncertain terms.
The days turned into weeks turned into months. He was being paid regardless. Every week Ford would show up at his door with an envelope. Never asked him a single question. Shepherd interpreted the look he saw in Ford’s face how he wanted. Eventually he stopped looking. Ford showed up every week anyway.
It was an idle moment fiddling on that “smart phone” his niece had bought for him after an incident where his Chevy had broken down and he hadn’t had his phone on him, his cheap, data plan phone that supplemented the landline he still used, the cellphone he never used, wasting time on Facebook, when he came across someone sharing Kate Meadows’ last post.
The post was entirely innocuous. If it hadn’t been her last no one would have noticed or cared. The fact is, as far as he could tell, and Shepherd was certainly no expert, unless you expressed something controversial or incriminating, no one cared what you told about yourself, your place in the world, especially if you weren’t trying to ingratiate yourself to some group identity. And that had been Kate’s one and only sin, the courage to drown without a lifeline. Shepherd went down the rabbit hole. He spent hours sifting through all her posts. Neither Bishop nor Malkovich had ever interacted with her material. She did post videos and photos of her relationship with Bishop, which was as far as Shepherd could tell why the media coverage had obsessed over him. An anonymous rascal, though, whom he suspected but couldn’t prove to be White, had constantly harassed her. She had chosen to disengage as much as possible. It hadn’t seemed to help.
That last post was about her dog. She’d been worried. She never had the chance to bring it to the vet. Shepherd made a note to warn Bradley about that.
That was also when he started sharing his thoughts, first with the dog walker, then Hodgson, then Gene Reid. They all agreed that Matt White was the likeliest suspect. It was Shepherd, though, who convinced Ford that charges should be pressed. The resulting trial couldn’t possibly be the media circus that had already been made out of the case. White was convicted, sentenced, and ended up in the same facility as Priscilla Foster.
That was when Shepherd made his first visit. He brought his new phone with him. He shared with Foster Kate’s Facebook posts. It was Foster who interpreted all the ones Kate had written about her, always worded from oblique angles, that Shepherd had overlooked. Foster quietly asked him to leave, then. Later, he thought he understood why.
Late at night he scrolled through Kate’s timeline. He’d never known her when she was alive. She was too young to register, when Foster’s problems occurred. That’s what he’d told himself, then. The next day, he waited patiently for the Andromeda & Ash to open. Kay Poole had been given the sword, after its release from the evidence locker. He asked to see it.
When he showed up at the Hawkeye, Ford was still there. They ended up talking about Kate for hours.